India’s corporate sector is significantly increasing its investment in research and development (R&D). However, a pressing issue emerges: the lack of market validation and demand for innovations is hindering their successful introduction. This situation creates a paradox where the potential for groundbreaking technologies exists, yet their uptake remains stymied by insufficient support from policies and a lack of trust in their efficacy.
Bottlenecks in Adoption
Despite the surge in R&D expenditures, the critical challenge lies in the adoption of new technologies rather than their invention. Industry leaders have noted that without governmental backing or established global precedents, many innovations fail to reach potential buyers. This commercial stagnation has left firms grappling with escalating R&D costs but minimal returns, as highlighted in a recent panel discussion at the Mint India Investment Summit.
Manufacturers are particularly impacted, with many expressing concerns about the lack of validation for their innovations both domestically and internationally. Pradeep Kumar Kheruka, executive chairman of Borosil Renewables Ltd, articulated this sentiment during the discussion, emphasizing that while R&D is flourishing, its commercial viability remains elusive.
Case Studies of Innovation Resistance
Kheruka showcased Borosil’s endeavor to produce antimony-free solar glass as a case in point. Despite demonstrating that antimony leaches from glass and advocating for its ban, the company faces resistance in adoption. In contrast, China has taken a decisive step by enforcing a ban on the chemical, demonstrating a willingness to embrace innovation that India has yet to replicate.
Another example from Borosil pertains to its development of a two-millimeter tempered glass, regarded as a world first. However, potential customers remain hesitant to adopt this innovation, primarily due to the absence of similar products in the market. This reluctance underscores a broader trend where groundbreaking innovations struggle to gain traction without established validation.
Investment in Renewable Technologies
The renewable energy sector is also experiencing similar challenges. Sael Industries has invested significantly in converting agricultural waste into energy, despite the costs being considerably higher than traditional methods. Laxit Awla, CEO of Sael, pointed out that their investment aims to prevent farmers from burning waste in open fields. This commitment to sustainability contrasts sharply with the market’s slow adoption of such initiatives.
Advancements in Manufacturing Processes
Beyond renewable energy, companies like Anupam Rasayan are focusing on enhancing their core manufacturing capabilities. The firm has made strides in advanced manufacturing techniques, particularly transitioning from continuous to flow manufacturing, which has significantly boosted efficiency and product quality. Gopal Agarwal, CEO of Anupam Rasayan, highlighted this achievement as a critical advancement for the company, reflecting a trend among Indian firms to innovate in their manufacturing processes.
R&D Investment Statistics
Despite these advancements, R&D intensity in India remains comparatively low. Borosil allocates approximately 3% of its EBITDA to R&D, while Sael invests around 1% of its revenue. Anupam Rasayan employs nearly 100 scientists across its research facilities, yet overall corporate spending on R&D is less than 1% of the ₹651.3 trillion spent by Indian companies over the past decade. In FY23, the R&D expenditure as a share of net sales was merely 0.3%, a decline from 0.4% in FY19.
The Need for Ecosystem Support
Executives assert that the primary obstacle lies in fostering an ecosystem that promotes the commercialization of innovations rather than merely increasing production capacity. A more robust policy framework is essential, one that not only incentivizes manufacturing but also actively encourages the adoption of new technologies. Kheruka suggested that the government should set clear targets for purchases to create assured demand for emerging innovations.
Aligning Incentives with Innovation
There is a pressing need to align incentives with the outcomes of innovation. Awla emphasized the importance of establishing parameters such as the R&D-to-sales ratio to encourage companies to accelerate their innovation efforts. Such measures could drive a more favorable environment for R&D investments, ultimately leading to greater commercialization of new technologies.
Government Support and Collaborative Innovation
The government’s production-linked incentive schemes have bolstered capital availability, allowing firms to invest more in innovation. These initiatives, with a total outlay of approximately ₹1.97 trillion, provide incentives of 4-6% on incremental sales across various sectors. This support enables companies to allocate funds toward R&D and innovation, as highlighted by Agarwal.
However, to build a sustainable innovation ecosystem, stronger collaboration between industry, academia, and government is essential. Agarwal emphasized the need for a unified approach, where all stakeholders work together to facilitate innovation.
The Role of Risk Capital
Finally, the availability of risk capital is crucial for fostering innovation, especially given the long timelines often required for new technologies to develop. Without adequate financial support, many promising innovations may never reach the market, stalling potential advancements in various sectors.
In conclusion, while India Inc. is making commendable strides in R&D, the path to effective commercialization remains fraught with challenges. By fostering a supportive ecosystem, aligning incentives with innovation outcomes, and enhancing collaborations across sectors, India can unlock the full potential of its R&D investments and drive sustainable growth.
- Key Takeaways:
- Adoption of innovations is hindered by lack of validation and market demand.
- Companies face resistance despite significant investments in groundbreaking technologies.
- The ecosystem must be enhanced to support commercialization rather than just capacity creation.
- Government policies should actively encourage technology adoption alongside manufacturing.
- Collaborative efforts among industry, government, and academia are crucial for fostering innovation.
Read more → www.livemint.com