Technological innovation serves as a critical engine for economic growth, yet India’s current landscape reveals a stark innovation gap primarily rooted in corporate investment behaviors. While public spending on research and development (R&D) often dominates discussions, it is essential to recognize that the reluctance of Indian businesses to invest significantly in R&D is a fundamental issue.
The recent CTIER Handbook on Technology and Innovation in India 2025 sheds light on several key aspects of this situation, revealing a troubling picture of India’s innovation capacity.
Structural Deficiencies in R&D Spending
India’s expenditure on R&D remains alarmingly low, standing at just 0.6% of GDP in 2023. This figure places India at the bottom among major innovation economies and reflects a persistent trend over the past three decades, with the expenditure fluctuating only between 0.6% and 0.9%. In contrast, peer nations such as Israel and South Korea invest over 4% of their GDP in R&D, while the United States surpasses 3.5% and China approaches 2.6%. These figures highlight the commitment of these nations to fostering technological leadership through robust investment in R&D.
Reliance on Government Funding
The dependency on government funding is another significant concern. As of 2023, the public sector accounted for a staggering 55% of total R&D expenditure in India, with industry contributing merely 36% and higher education accounting for 9%. This contrasts sharply with global trends, where industry typically funds 75–80% of R&D in countries like the US and China, emphasizing the critical role corporations play in driving innovation.
Declining Industrial Investment
Recent data indicates a worrying decline in industrial investment in R&D. The share of industry in India’s total R&D has fallen from 41% in 2018 to 36% in 2023. In stark terms, India’s industrial R&D expenditure in 2023 was under $7.4 billion. For perspective, Nvidia, a leading technology company, spends nearly the same amount on R&D as the entire Indian industrial sector, while Alphabet, the top global spender, allocates almost five times that sum. This trend raises significant concerns about India’s long-term competitiveness in the global market.
Concentration of R&D in Select Sectors
The pattern of industrial R&D spending in India reflects a troubling concentration in a few sectors, primarily pharmaceuticals, automobiles, oil and gas, and software services. Together, these sectors account for over half of India’s total industrial R&D expenditure. In contrast, sectors that are critical for global R&D, such as electronics, healthcare technology, and advanced manufacturing, receive comparatively little investment.
This narrow focus has tangible consequences. In 2023, only 22 Indian corporations appeared among the world’s top 2,500 R&D spenders, a stark contrast to the 827 US and 679 Chinese companies on the list. Furthermore, Indian firms are notably absent from six of the ten most R&D-intensive global sectors, which underscores a significant gap in technological advancement.
The Role of Large Corporates
The behavior of large Indian corporates further exacerbates the situation. The top 100 R&D spenders dominate the landscape, accounting for nearly 78% of all industrial R&D in India. Beyond this small group, R&D spending drops significantly. Many profitable Indian companies with substantial global revenues invest little in in-house research, often relying on foreign technologies or incremental improvements instead.
Talent and Research Pipeline Challenges
India faces critical challenges in building a strong talent and research pipeline. In 2022, the country had only 260 full-time researchers per million people, a figure that pales in comparison to China’s 1,849 and the US’s 4,825. While India produces a considerable number of PhDs in science and engineering, the transition from academic output to impactful research remains weak. Despite ranking fifth globally in research publications, India struggles with low citation impact scores, indicating that much of the research produced does not reach the forefront of global scientific discourse.
Need for Industry Collaboration
The lack of collaboration between industry and academia compounds these challenges. Only 1% of research publications involve industry partnerships, significantly lower than in countries like Japan and Germany. While there has been some progress in patent filings, the overall scale of innovation remains below that of China’s robust local system.
Conclusion: A Call for a Cultural Shift
India’s innovation gap is apparent in corporate financial statements, sectoral choices, and the absence of Indian firms in cutting-edge technologies. While initiatives like the Anusandhan National Research Foundation and the India AI Mission signal recognition of these issues, their success hinges on reshaping corporate attitudes toward R&D.
To close this gap, Indian industry must recognize R&D as a cornerstone of sustainable competitiveness rather than a mere adjunct to growth. Only through a cultural shift that prioritizes innovation and fosters deeper collaboration between industry and academia can India hope to reclaim its position as a leader in global innovation.
- Key Takeaways:
- India’s R&D expenditure is among the lowest globally, highlighting a critical innovation gap.
- Industry funding for R&D remains disproportionately low compared to government investment.
- A narrow focus on select sectors limits the potential for broad-based technological advancement.
- Greater collaboration between industry and academia is essential for impactful research.
- A cultural shift toward prioritizing R&D within corporates is necessary for long-term competitiveness.
Read more → www.livemint.com